Enlarged Prostate vs Prostate Cancer: Key Differences

Clinician explaining enlarged prostate vs prostate cancer with a prostate model.

Many men notice a weaker stream or more trips to the bathroom at night and worry about prostate cancer. More often, the cause is an enlarged prostate, a noncancerous growth called benign prostatic hyperplasia or BPH. Early prostate cancer usually causes no symptoms at all. BPH does not turn into cancer. A man can still have both.

The sections below explain how the two differ, which symptoms matter, how doctors tell them apart and how an enlarged prostate is treated.

Key takeaways

  • BPH is a noncancerous growth that commonly causes urinary problems in older men.
  • Early prostate cancer usually causes no symptoms.
  • BPH does not turn into cancer or raise cancer risk.
  • A high PSA blood test can come from either condition. It calls for more tests rather than giving an answer.

What is the difference between an enlarged prostate and prostate cancer?

The prostate is a walnut-sized gland below the bladder that wraps around the tube that carries urine out of the body. BPH is normal prostate tissue that keeps growing with age but stays inside the gland. Prostate cancer is made of abnormal cells that can spread beyond it.

Feature Enlarged prostate or BPH Prostate cancer
What it is Noncancerous growth Cancer that can spread
Where it usually starts Inner part of the gland Outer edge of the gland
Early symptoms Weak stream, sudden urges, nighttime trips Usually none
Effect on PSA blood test Can raise it Can raise it
How it is confirmed Symptoms, exam and scans MRI scan and biopsy

Where each one grows explains why the symptoms differ. BPH usually starts in the inner part of the gland that hugs the urine tube. Even modest growth there can squeeze it. Most prostate cancers start in the outer edge of the gland and can grow for years without affecting how a man urinates.

How common are BPH and prostate cancer?

BPH is very common. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases reports that it affects about half of men aged 51 to 60 and up to 90% of men over 80.

Prostate cancer is less common. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force puts the lifetime chance of a prostate cancer diagnosis at about 11%. The risk is higher for Black men and for men whose father or brother has had the disease.

Can an enlarged prostate turn into cancer?

No. According to the National Cancer Institute, BPH does not become cancer and does not raise the risk of prostate cancer.

A man can still have both at the same time. A BPH diagnosis therefore does not replace regular screening conversations with a doctor.

Which symptoms point to BPH and which to cancer?

BPH symptoms usually build slowly over months or years. The most common ones are:

  • Waking at night to urinate
  • A sudden, strong urge to urinate
  • A weak or stop-and-start stream
  • A feeling that the bladder has not fully emptied

Nighttime trips are not always a prostate problem. Evening drinks, water pills, diabetes and swollen legs can cause them too, as explained in why people keep waking up to pee at night.

Prostate cancer usually shows signs only once it is more advanced. The National Cancer Institute lists signs such as blood in the urine or semen and pain in the back, hips or pelvis that does not go away. Any of these should be checked promptly, even in a man already told he has BPH.

When do urinary symptoms need urgent care?

Suddenly being unable to urinate is a medical emergency, according to the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases. It usually causes painful swelling in the lower belly and needs prompt care, often with a thin tube to drain the bladder.

Blood in the urine, fever, burning when urinating or passing very little urine despite a strong urge also need attention soon. These can point to an infection, bladder stones or a blockage.

How do doctors tell BPH and prostate cancer apart?

The PSA test is a simple blood test that measures a protein made by the prostate. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force notes that BPH and prostate swelling can raise PSA, not only cancer. One high result is a reason for more testing rather than a diagnosis.

Some BPH medicines also change the reading. The FDA prescribing information for finasteride states that it lowers PSA by about half. Men taking it should mention this before any PSA test. When PSA or a physical exam raises concern, an MRI scan can highlight suspicious areas. A biopsy, which takes tiny tissue samples, is the only way to confirm cancer.

At VascuHealth in Largo, MD, urinary symptoms, PSA history and any earlier scans are reviewed together before treatment is discussed.

Should men get screened for prostate cancer?

Under its 2018 recommendation, which is currently being updated, the U.S. Preventive Services Task Force advises men aged 55 to 69 to decide about PSA screening together with their doctor. It recommends against routine screening for men 70 and older.

Screening is meant for men without symptoms. Men with new urinary changes should see a doctor rather than wait for a routine check.

How is an enlarged prostate treated without surgery?

Medicines are often the first step. Some relax the muscle around the urine tube to improve flow. Others slowly shrink the gland.

When medicines stop helping, prostate artery embolization is one option for men who want to avoid surgery. The doctor passes a thin tube through a small needle puncture in the wrist or groin and uses live X-ray images to reach the arteries feeding the prostate. Tiny particles reduce the blood supply so the gland can slowly shrink. Most men stay awake, with numbing medicine and light sedation.

Before the procedure, vascular diagnostic testing maps the small arteries that supply the prostate. A PSA review also helps confirm that symptoms come from benign growth rather than cancer. Dr. Nwosu, a fellowship-trained, dual board-certified interventional radiologist, has approximately 6.5 years of experience and approximately 10,000+ image-guided procedures.

Frequently Asked Questions

What PSA level is considered normal?

There is no single normal level for every man. The National Cancer Institute notes that many doctors once treated 4.0 or lower as normal. Doctors now look at how the number changes over time, along with age and other risk factors.

Can an enlarged prostate damage the kidneys?

In rare cases, yes. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases lists kidney damage as a possible complication of severe blockage that goes untreated.

Does prostate artery embolization treat prostate cancer?

No. It treats urinary symptoms caused by a noncancerous enlarged prostate. Prostate cancer is managed by urologists and cancer specialists.

Can cutting back on evening drinks help an enlarged prostate?

It may help with nighttime trips to the bathroom. The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases suggests limiting fluids before bedtime and cutting back on caffeine and alcohol.

How long do enlarged prostate medicines take to work?

Medicines that relax the prostate muscle often help within days to weeks. Medicines that shrink the gland, such as finasteride, can take up to six months for full effect, according to the FDA prescribing information.

This article is for general information only and is not medical advice. Please speak with a doctor about your symptoms and treatment options.